Understanding Judge Judy in the American Legal System

Stop Watching TV! It's time to differentiate between reality and fiction. Judge Judy is not a figure in the traditional sense of the legal system, but rather a civil arbitrator who resolves disputes in a television courtroom. This article will clarify her role and the broader context of the entertainment-based legal system.

What is Judge Judy's Role?

People often turn to Judge Judy as an alternative to traditional small claims court. This format is particularly appealing for minor civil cases involving small amounts of money. Unlike a legal judge, Judge Judy does not have the power to send anyone to jail. Her role is to act as an impartial arbitrator for parties who have agreed to her decision.

Her Background and Credibility

Judge Judy, whose real name is Marilyn Milgrom, has a rich background in the legal field. She was a prosecutor and a real judge, which lends her the necessary credentials to appear on a television court. The program she hosts is primarily for entertainment, but it operates within a structured legal framework. Both parties in a case have filed a complaint and agree to have her hear and decide their case, similar to going to arbitration or mediation.

Legal Context and Free Speech

It's important to understand that Judge Judy's presence in this capacity is a result of the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech. Like other fields such as witch doctors, shamans, chiropractors, and faith healers, binding arbitration is a part of the legal system. Her role can be seen as a form of public mediation and arbitration within the entertainment industry, adhering to certain legal principles and procedures.

The Show and Its Impact

It's crucial to distinguish between Judge Judy's television persona and her legal background. While on the show, she is referred to as a judge for the sake of the program's appeal. In reality, she acts as a binding arbitrator. The agreement to have her hear the case is made between the two parties, rather than being mandated by a court. These small claims matters, often involving petty disputes, are addressed in this informal manner.

Entertainment vs. Legal System

Judge Judy has transformed from a real judge to an entertainer. Her role is to provide an entertaining and accessible way to resolve minor disputes. While the show presents some legal principles, the emphasis on scolding and dramatic elements is more for showbiz appeal. The small claims cases seen on the show are often handled by individuals who may not fully understand the legal process, leading to their reliance on advice and judgments presented.

Conclusion

Despite the unique format and entertainment aspects of Judge Judy and similar shows, they operate within a legal framework. Binding arbitration, like that implemented in these shows, is a part of the American legal system. It provides an accessible and informal method for resolving minor disputes, catering to the public's need for an alternative to traditional legal proceedings.

Understanding the difference between entertainment and the legal system is key to appreciating the role of Judge Judy. While there is room for criticism in the legal system, the presence of shows like Judge Judy can be seen as a valuable addition, offering an accessible and engaging method for resolving disputes.